This week, two major court decisions in Belgium and France have highlighted the issue of sexual violence and the quest for justice for victims. These cases, while highlighting personal tragedies, also reveal structural shortcomings in the protection of victims and the treatment of aggressors. Here is an analysis of these two cases and their wider societal implications.
The Julie Van Espen Affair (Belgium)
Julie Van Espen, a 23-year-old woman, was raped and murdered by Steve Bakelmans in May 2019. This week, a Brussels court held the Belgian state responsible for the crime. The verdict highlighted serious failings in the judicial system, which failed to effectively monitor the attacker despite his previous rape convictions. This lack of control enabled him to claim a new victim.
Julie's family called for official recognition and an apology from the Belgian state. This judgment is of major legal importance, as it holds the State responsible for its judicial shortcomings. It paves the way for reforms and a critical assessment of the management of such cases. This case highlights the need to improve procedures to identify repeat offenders and protect potential victims.
The Gisèle Pélicot Affair (France)
In France, the Gisèle Pélicot case ended with her husband, Dominique Pélicot, being sentenced to 20 years in prison. He was found guilty of systematically drugging his wife and allowing dozens of men to rape her over a nine-year period. Gisèle's courageous testimony and determination to obtain justice, despite immense social pressure and shame, is a powerful example of resilience.
This case has broken the silence surrounding sexual violence in domestic relationships and highlighted the importance of clear legislation and strict prosecution of these crimes. It also shows the crucial role of help and support for victims in overcoming the obstacles they face in their quest for justice.
Symbolic and legal significance
Both cases have profound symbolic value. They expose systemic failings in the protection of victims and the effective treatment of aggressors. At the same time, they offer hope by bringing recognition and justice to victims and their families. They underline the need to reform judicial and societal structures so that sexual violence does not go unpunished.
The Way Forward
These judicial decisions are not just individual victories; they are a call to action. Governments, judicial bodies and social organizations must work together to improve victim protection. This includes:
- Stricter enforcement of existing laws and regulations.
- Better surveillance and control of aggressors, especially repeat offenders.
- Increased resources for victim support and psychological assistance.
- Lifting taboos and raising awareness of sexual violence.
A just and safe society begins by acknowledging failures and taking responsibility. By highlighting the stories of Julie Van Espen and Gisèle Pélicot, we can continue to advocate reforms that truly meet the needs of victims. Together, we can work towards a society where sexual violence is not just condemned, but actively prevented.
Need help with your application? Contact us for professional assistance!